Start chewing.
You literally admitted it in your own comment: “Sure, it’s not something humans had gotten to yet.”
That is the definition of a novel discovery.
You are arguing that because the AI used logic and existing data to reach the conclusion, it doesn’t count. By that definition, no human scientist has ever had a novel idea either since we all build on existing data and patterns.
The AI looked at the same data humans had, saw a pattern humans missed, and created a solution humans didn’t have. That is novelty.
But honestly it is hard to take your analysis of these papers seriously when you just argued in the comment above that protein folding involves “10^2 combinations.”
You realize 10^2 is just 100 right?
You think complex biology is a list shorter than a grocery receipt. If your math is off by about 300 zeros I am not sure you are the best judge of what these models are actually capable of.
Start chewing. You literally admitted it in your own comment: “Sure, it’s not something humans had gotten to yet.” That is the definition of a novel discovery. You are arguing that because the AI used logic and existing data to reach the conclusion, it doesn’t count. By that definition, no human scientist has ever had a novel idea either since we all build on existing data and patterns. The AI looked at the same data humans had, saw a pattern humans missed, and created a solution humans didn’t have. That is novelty. But honestly it is hard to take your analysis of these papers seriously when you just argued in the comment above that protein folding involves “10^2 combinations.” You realize 10^2 is just 100 right? You think complex biology is a list shorter than a grocery receipt. If your math is off by about 300 zeros I am not sure you are the best judge of what these models are actually capable of.
No, that’s not what novel ideation is whatsoever 🤦
Again…these models work from a list of boundaries, logic, and rules made by humans. They don’t make it up themselves because…they.fucking.cant.
If they could make their own rules and conclusions without human intervention, then you have novel ideas. But…they.100%.FUCKING.CANT.DO.THAT.