brandon

The problem is that federal income taxes are generally paid directly by employers to the federal government. It’s not clear by what mechanism states and/or cities might withhold them.

It’s true that the State of New York, and NYC are both large employers, so hypothetically I guess they could refuse to collect income taxes from their employees on behalf of the federal government, but certainly the IRS would still hold the individual taxpayers responsible for those taxes at the end of the year.

The cruelty is the point.

In the John version of the story, he “drives” them out of the temple with a whip. It’s difficult to reconcile that with a total pacifism.

Pacifist

Did I misread the part when he kicks the shit out of the money changers?

I don’t know how they could implement this across the private sector, but the State of California has a quarter million employees for which they could probably stop sending tax withholdings to the feds.

According to this random site I found Googling, it’s around $230M every month.

I am saying that:

1. the vast majority of violence perpetrated at these demonstrations is done by law enforcement
2. if cops wanted people to stop throwing water bottles at them they would stop trampling people with horses and shooting reporters with rubber bullets
3. framing these demonstrations as “violent” only serves the narrative of the right

It’s textbook manufacturing of consent

They will say that regardless of how much violence protesters actually do. Purity testing demonstrations only makes the situation worse by allowing the right the ability to dictate the narrative.

As an additional point to add to yours, every single political protest movement in history has included violent elements. It’s unavoidable. When these political “moderates” start pearl clutching about some windows being broken or whatever it is an attempt to de-legitimize the entire movement, and draw the focus away from the actual source of the majority of violence, the cops (including ICE).

Protestors should start bringing packs of Crayola to lure them across the line.

Careful how you phrase this. The right wing anti-woke crusaders will retort “oh, so you’re saying this level of CO2 is natural after all?”