• 0 Posts
  • 36 Comments
Joined 9 months ago
cake
Cake day: July 21st, 2024

help-circle


  • it’s okay in some amounts since you’re getting radiation doses every day even not living near anything nuclear).

    And people get cancer every day. I don’t share their argument that NPPs in normal operation are a risk, but OP is somewhat right, there’s no safe radiation dose, just one we deem safe enough mainly because it doesn’t significantly raise our risk of cancer compared to the natural exposure. And NPPs in normal operation emit less radiation than for example coal fire plants.


  • FFS, people are stupid.

    There was a huge hysteria about nuclear when Fukushima happened. A clear majority was for immediate action. Merkel’s coalition government would have ended if she hadn’t done a 180 on nuclear and decided to shut down nuclear as soon as possible, which was 2023. I was against shutting it down back then but I thought you can’t go against the whole population, so I get why they did it. People didn’t change their mind until 2022. Nobody talked about reversing that decision in all these years when there was actually time to reverse the decision.

    Now, that the last reactor is shut down, the same people that were up in arms in 2011 are now up in arms that we don’t have nuclear. Building new plants will cost billions and take decades and nuclear doesn’t work well with renewables because of its inflexibility. It makes no sense at all. It was a long-term decision we can’t just back away from. What’s done is done.















  • Look into survivorship bias. The only 90 year old smokers you see are of course the ones that survived.

    The statistic is an average. The 30 year old non-smoker being killed in an accident is an outlier exactly the same as the 90 year old that still smokes on the way to their grave. You might not lose anything because you die before you get lung cancer or you lose much more because you develop it at 40 years old, but on average a smoker loses 20 min per cigarette.

    That’s how these statistics usually work:

    (life expectancy of non-smokers - life expectancy of smokers) / # cigarettes an average smoker smokes in their lifetime

    Obviously, it’s not literally like “that one cigarette ends your life 20 minutes earlier”.